Your Cart is Empty

A Discussion on Obesity (That Isn't Flagrantly Annoying).

November 21, 2013 6 min read

If you want to watch the world go crazy, just become a specialist in something. Specialists arguing amongst themselves can reach a frenzied pitch of nonsense faster than the U.S. congressional chamber at an open bar.
Two shots of Wild Turkey and dude thinks he's Thor.
Two shots of Wild Turkey and dude thinks he's Thor.
  One of the only ways to combat this kind of implosion is to bring in outside voices: relevant but removed, useful but tangential. As a fitness specialist, that means occasionally asking people outside my field about how they view and work with bodies. Heidi Guenin is a public policy analyst out of Portland, Oregon. She has a masters in urban and regional planning from Portland State University and will be completing another in public health from Oregon Health and Science University in 2014. As someone who thinks about issues of health and fitness at the population level, I was eager to get her perspective on that omnipresent boogeyman haunting every discussion of exercise on the internet and beyond: obesity. I hope you'll find her views as refreshing as I did. For those unfamiliar with the role of a public health policy maker, in 20 words or less, what do you do? As a public health policy researcher and advocate, I examine population-level health behaviors and outcomes to better understand which policies are needed to support health. That’s more than 20 words, but if it’s ok, I’m going to use up a few more while I'm at it. We are particularly interested in health inequalities: where one or more groups suffer a disproportionate share of an illness or disease.  Sometimes these inequalities are natural due to differences in age, gender, or other variables. Sometimes they are the result of unfairness in our social, economic, and physical environments. Public health policy folks like myself want to understand this second group of inequalities and eliminate them.  
Public policy advocates: warriors of social justice, only with fewer swords and more epidemiological data.
Public policy advocates: warriors of social justice, only with fewer swords and more epidemiological data.
  How do you translate data about the behavior of whole populations into usable information for individuals? My job is to translate health data into policy prescriptions for the people who make public health decisions: politicians, administrators, etc. Decision-makers want to hear about the bottom line: the costs of any policies or programs that promote health. There are plenty of places Photo 12-11-13 2 15 47 pmwhere we can find numbers—staggeringly high numbers—that are being pinned on obesity (and therefore on fat people themselves).  So instead of making the case for quality of life, better health outcomes, or safer and more livable communities, we often find ourselves making the case for reduced health care spending through reduced obesity. This might win us a few votes, but it certainly doesn’t attract many folks to our cause or inspire community members to join in the discussion. So what you’re saying is that the idea of reducing public spending by reducing obesity gets policy makers all fired up, but doesn't do much to inspire the people living in those communities. Why is there such a disconnect? I wish I knew. I could blame it on the current political climate where it's more common to assign blame than develop effective solutions, and where the call for individual responsibility trumps the need for compassion. Public investments—mechanisms designed to improve the well-being of society as a whole—are increasingly treated like private investments with a predictable return of investment. Even the economist in me doesn't understand. We know that inequality is bad for our economy, and this focus on the cost of obesity only serves to increase health inequalities for people who are stigmatized.  And I don't imagine anyone ever decided to take a walk or hop on a bike because they were made to feel bad about their share of national health care costs.
"Hey guys, wanna go reduce our combined impact on public healthcare spending?" —No one, ever
Obesity is a very common topic in public health policy, and I’d argue that it receives far too much emphasis.  The growing focus on the “obesity epidemic” and on the rising cost of medical spending have created an environment where it is too convenient and common for public health folks, myself included, to rely on obesity as a scapegoat. So, is obesity even considered a "health outcome"? A health outcome is thought of in terms of morbidity (illness) and mortality (death).  So the question you're really asking me is: "Is obesity an illness?"  I don't have an answer for you. It's a very controversial question.
Pictured: Lebron James, BMI 27.5 Also pictured: NOT SOMEONE WITH A WEIGHT PROBLEM.
Pictured: Lebron James, BMI 27.5 Also pictured: NOT SOMEONE WITH A WEIGHT PROBLEM.
Just this year, the American Medical Association voted to classify obesity as a disease, contrary to the recommendation of its own Council on Science and Public Health.  The Council had noted that body mass index (BMI) is a flawed metric and that labeling obesity as a disease would not serve to improve health outcomes. But the AMA's new designation of obesity as a disease creates a stronger case for insurers to cover anti-obesity drugs and surgeries such as stomach-stapling. If obesity is a disease, then if you're obese, losing weight should be a goal in and of itself. But here's the thing: you can be fat and still be metabolically healthy. We tell people that if they lose weight, they will reduce their risk of many diseases—including cardiovascular disease, diabetes, some types of cancer, and coronary heart disease—but increasing physical activity levels also results in these risk reductions, even if the physical activity doesn't result in weight loss.

So I assume, then, it wasn't the "obesity epidemic" that got you into this gig, right?

Heidi, being awesome.
Heidi, being awesome.
I got started working on transportation issues, which came about mostly because I love the fun and freedom that comes with being able to ride my bike and walk around my neighborhood.  But when I talk about bicycling from a public-health perspective, it’s easier to emphasize the health and financial benefits of obesity reduction. Which is just plain silly; I don’t want someone to take up bicycling just because it will help them lose weight. That’s a recipe for disappointment and frustration and doesn’t support sustainable healthy choices. Doesn't it? That may come as a surprise to many. Can you explain? The researcher who first got me interested in the role that shame plays in behavior change is Brene Brown at the University of Houston. She's written a couple of popular books on the subject of shame and guilt, and I'd definitely recommend those to anyone interested in examining how shame negatively affects our mental and physical health.  big-man-252x335 But stigma is more widely studied than shame.  A 2010 literature review on obesity stigmatization found that "...weight stigma is not a beneficial public health tool for reducing obesity. Rather, stigmatization of obese individuals threatens health, generates health disparities, and interferes with effective obesity intervention efforts." Approaches that are more oriented toward weight acceptance and empowerment, however, show great promise in helping people increase their physical activity. How would you like to see the conversation change? I’m not prepared to argue that there are no negative health outcomes that stem from obesity, but we all need to question many of our underlying assumptions about weight and how we support people trying to improve their health. In my perfect world, we would advocate for better bike infrastructure and safer neighborhood streets, not because people might lose weight, but because they’d have more fun, sleep better, be less at risk for depression, cancer, heart disease, and a host of other illnesses. And we’d stop, even inadvertently, sending fat people the message that there is something inherently wrong with them. Are there any organizations out there getting it right? I’m a fan of the Health at Every Size model; they have many resources on their site. Health interventions that use weight acceptance as a foundation have been very successful; they have better retention rates and don’t result in as much weight cycling. What is weight cycling? Weight cycling, or yo-yoing, may be responsible for some of the mortality risk that is often attributed to obesity itself. The mechanism by which this happens is still being studied. Obesity research has for too long just assumed as a given that weight loss is a positive and important goal. This even though there is much we don’t fully understand about the impact of obesity on health outcomes, even though much of the research does not account for physical activity or for unhealthy weight yo-yoing, even though overweight has been shown to be protective of health, even though we understand that shame and stigma are not effective ways to help people change their behavior. So does knowing all these things affect the way you live? As an individual struggling with how to translate this information into my daily life, I’ve settled on a few first steps: I try my hardest to not make assumptions about a person because of their weight. Old habits die hard, but the research and my own cadre of fat fit friends make it harder and harder for me to buy into the idea that thin = healthy. I also don’t exercise to lose weight. Even though that little voice in my head still speaks up sometimes to remind me that I’m still the same weight I was yesterday or last month or last year, there’s another voice, too. It reminds me that I’m going to have better sex today and sleep better tonight, that next time I’ll be able to run a little farther or lift a little more weight, and that I’m giving my future body the gift of many more years of riding my bike down forest trails or dancing the night away.

Leave a comment

Also in BodyRock Store Blog

Image of Bodyrock blog article - What Happens To Your Butt When You Sit All Day?
What Happens To Your Butt When You Sit All Day?

July 14, 2019 3 min read 477 Comments

Do you think your booty looks a little flat? This might be why!
Read More
Image of Bodyrock blog article - 12 Ways To Make Your Belly Flatter By The End Of The Day
12 Ways To Make Your Belly Flatter By The End Of The Day

July 08, 2017 4 min read 43 Comments

Read More
Image of Bodyrock blog article - 7 Ways To Stop Binge Eating In It's Tracks
7 Ways To Stop Binge Eating In It's Tracks

June 22, 2017 2 min read 2 Comments

Do you ever find yourself knuckle-deep in a bag of Cheetos?
Read More
Shipping & Delivery

Due to COVID-19, shipping systems the world over are experiencing abnormal delays. There is an enormous demand on postal and delivery services as online shopping has skyrocketed, due to store closures and stay-at-home mandates. This is an unprecedented situation, and we are working around the clock to fulfill your orders as quickly as possible. To be clear, we are filling orders in 4-6 days, and we are shipping immediately after that. Once shipped, our shipping partner, UPS, will get your order out to you as quickly as possible. Thanks for your support and understanding.

Are you in Canada? Specifically, are you outside of a metropolitan centre? We need to alert you to a disruption in shipping due to COVID-19. Our preferred shipping provider, UPS, has informed us that they cannot guarantee express shipping for many locations. We have also seen that packages delivered to Toronto, Ottawa, Vancouver, etc, are not waylaid, but packages delivered to areas just outside of these cities are being held in transit for days or even weeks. UPS has discontinued their guarantee of 1-4 day delivery, which you can read more about here. Therefore, we can guarantee early fulfillment but not early delivery of our goods from our warehouse to your door at this time.

We want you to start your fitness journey with us as quickly as possible, that’s why we send every package to the USA & Canada via expedited or standard shipping (whichever is faster) with our partners at UPS. Once your order has been processed successfully we try to have your shipment prepared within 4-6 business days, and it typically takes 2-4 days to get to you once it leaves our warehouse.

We currently DO NOT SHIP to locations outside of the US and Canada. We DO NOT ship to a P.O. Box number.

We ship all of our physical products with UPS, from our warehouse location in Kingston, Ontario, Canada. Sometimes delivery can be delayed by circumstances out of our control, like postal & custom delays, back-ordered products or incorrectly entered shipping addresses. If there is a delay at Customs, a representative of UPS may contact you to provide your identification in order to receive your package. Please do this ASAP: Customers will be responsible for any additional shipping fees for failure to provide the required information to release a shipment.

Make sure when checking out and paying for your order that all of your information entered is correct! If you notice a mistake in your address, please try to contact us before your order is processed for shipping to avoid any missed shipments or delays. As soon as we process your order for shipping, you will receive a shipping confirmation email that contains your UPS tracking number. You can head on over to the UPS Website to see where your products are. Note: tracking information may take 1-2 business days to be updated in the UPS system

If you are not home when your package is delivered, BodyRock is NOT responsible if it is stolen. Please contact us if this happens to you and we will provide you with all the information needed to take the next steps.
Returns & Exchanges

BodyRock Equipment

We offer a 30-day return policy, as long as: it is not more than 30 days past the date of delivery; and your item is in its original condition and packaging with the original order number. Refunds will be issued when the equipment is received back to the BodyRock warehouse, minus the original cost of shipping, and the customer is responsible for the costs of return shipping. To request a refund on physical product purchases, please contact us.

Digital Products

We cannot issue refunds on digital goods such as e-books or videos, as these are non-tangible goods that are irrevocable once the order is placed.


All of the BodyRock clothing is made to order and so is final sale. If you have any questions about sizing prior to placing your order, please contact us.